Coquitlam repair shop fire insurance claim gets dismissed

More than 12 years after a fire tore through Trinity Auto Center, the property owner’s lawsuit against her insurance company was dismissed in B.C. Supreme Court.
Kulwinder Kaur Sanghera sued her insurance agency, Gold Key, for: “negligent failure to obtain the proper insurance” on the property at 513 Clarke Rd. in Coquitlam. Between lost rent and a reduced sale price, the fire cost the owners approximately $170,000, they contended.
Gold Key disputed that figure, contending the auto shop wasn’t paying rent at the time of the fire.
Local news that matters to you
No one covers the Tri-Cities like we do. But we need your help to keep our community journalism sustainable.
Sanghera and her husband Jagjit owned six properties in the city, including a nearby pizza shop and the Clarke Road home.
When the home was rezoned to allow for a repair shop, the change “should have been obvious” to their longtime insurance representative Sukhdarshan Sandhu, Sanghera contended.
Sandhu denied being told about the zoning change, adding the change wasn’t obvious to him as a passerby.
The couple charged that Gold Key and Sandhu, “failed to exercise their duty of care and negligently omitted to make updates” related to the insurance policy.
Sandhu disputed this characterization, responding that he would have been motivated to make the change to earn a higher commission.
After a fire in March 2014 destroyed much of the building, Sandhu submitted an insurance claim. The claim was rejected as the property was insured as a single-family rental dwelling.
The two parties also disagreed on several key details.
During the trial, Jagjit Sanghera maintained that he spoke to Sandhu twice on the phone about the zoning change. However, that account conflicted with previous evidence, noted Justice Simon Coval.
“In examination for discovery, however, he repeatedly testified to . . . telling Mr. Sandhu only once,” Coval stated.
At the time of the fire, the Sangheras were in the process of selling two Clarke Road properties including the Trinity Auto Center site for approximately $7 million. However, that price dropped by between $90,000 and $100,000 due to the fire, they stated.
However, Coval noted that Jagjit Sanghera couldn’t recall the exact purchase price nor how it was negotiated.
Ultimately, Sanghera failed to prove Sandhu breached his duty. The couple also didn’t prove, on a balance of probabilities, that they told Sandhu about the zoning change, Coval concluded.
“The most likely explanation for why Mr. Sandhu never switched the insurance to a commercial policy is that he never knew of the changes,” Coval wrote. “It defies common sense that Mr. Sandhu was told of the changes but simply forgot to change the coverage. Even if the changes might have initially slipped his mind, it would have come back to him at some point between 2007-2014, during all of his interactions with the Sangheras.”
The justice also concluded that a reasonable person might have driven by the site and not noticed the change, as the exterior still resembled a family home.
The claim was dismissed.
